We tried to sell our home this year. We wanted to downsize our space, in keeping with simplicity. And we wanted to downsize our mortgage, in keeping with reality. But no matter how much equity we were willing to sacrifice, our low-ball asking price attracted no buyers. After dozens of showings the primary complaint we heard over and over (and over and over) again was: “We love the house, but the power lines behind the back fence will ruin our view.”
Some people don’t like power lines. I get it. Of course, the power lines absolutely ensure that no other homes will be built behind ours. It’s just open field. Well, not quite open. It is filled with coastal sage and rabbits and quail and snakes and coyotes. In the daytime red tailed hawks perch on the huge iron towers that hold up the power lines, scanning the field for prey. At night owls keep us awake hooting so loudly it sounds like they are sitting in the ornamental olive tree crammed into our tiny backyard. Perhaps they are.
Last week Leanne and I were in Nashville for Hutchmoot. It is not easy to explain the gathering, so I am not going to even try. Yet I will mention that Wendell Berry’s name came up a lot.
It sounds too fancy for me to say that Wendell Berry is a literary mentor of mine, though I consider him to be. The first book of his I owned was a collection of his Sabbath poems that I purchased when I was still in high school. For over twenty years I have been reading Wendell Berry. His poetry, essays, and fiction. That sounds more impressive than it is. I have never memorized long passages of his works, like some friends of mine. I have gone long stints without reading his poems, unlike some friends of mine. I have only read Jayber Crow twice and, though I still marvel at it, have come to think that Jayber and Mattie were both more than a touch dysfunctional. For some, I am no doubt a Wendell Berry heretic.
I might as well go all the way then. Reading Wendell Berry for two decades has given me the impression that it is not possible to find home cooking in the suburbs. Suburbanites don’t faithfully make love; they have affairs or wished they did. Suburbanites only leave their homes by backing their SUVs out of their garages so that they don’t risk having to talk with their neighbors. They leave their TVs running for their pets.
It is all true. The suburbs are filled with people living in sin and driving in gas-guzzlers and microwaving frozen foods. It’s just that there are people like that living in Port William, too.
I believe it is not Wendell Berry’s intention to create this impression, though I think he sometimes does. He sometimes gives you the sense that you will find a more honest and natural kind of person, if you will only abandon the suburbs and become an agrarian. Perhaps you will. Actually, I’m sure you will. But in doing so you will become the very kind of person Wendell Berry disdains the most. The kind of person who abandons community in search of something better.
“If enough of us were to choose caring over not caring, staying over going, then the culture would change, the theme of exploitation would become subordinate to the theme of settlement, and the choice to be a sticker would become easier. The necessary examples would be more numerous and more available. The way would be clearer.” (Another Turn of the Crank)
Over the last week I have been working on my post-Hutchmoot reflection. It has been coming together as a song. It’s still rough and always will be since I’m not a songwriter. There is still work to be done on it. And my suburban life.
Behind a fence rejected by many strangers,‘cause there’s power stretched across the sky.
In modest hollows scratched under coastal sage,
a warren on display is God’s amazing grace. Behind the house our daughters only know,
a mighty bird will leave its fortress in the sky
to crush a serpent with its talons strong,
then use the mess it’s made to hush its crying young. Through tears we escape down many roads,
then seek our solace from those who never left their homes.
It takes a humbled life to bend before its place
and stay.
Comments
This was the first thing I read this morning. What a great way to start my day – thank you.
Oh, and after hearing your description and reading your lyrics, I’d buy the place, power lines be damned
Good luck in that venture.
When I was reading this I could not help but think, “yes, but, some of us are not leaving community so much as seeking community!”
For many long years I have been seeking community that not only cares for its members and respects them, but is a place where diversity is truly revered rather than paid lip service to. A community where I can be who I am and love who I am drawn to. A community that not only espouses the ideals of peace and justice but practices them. A community that gives back to the Earth as much as the Earth gives to them.
I have not yet found that place, though once upon a time we had many such places. But that was a very long time ago.
What I do in the interim, as I search, is live my life traveling North America in my pickup truck camper combo with my two cats. It is not always easy but it is better than what I had before. If you’ve read Steinbeck’s “Travels With Charlie” you will have some idea of how it is, though my rig is far larger and better appointed than what he had. I’ve met wonderful people along the way, including some who came to my aid in a little town on the Oregon coast after a particularly nasty mountain bike crash I had. But for the fact the days are too dark and short as well as drizzly and snowy I would have made a home by now on the Oregon coast or in Portland.
I am also drawn to Central America . . . in particular to Nicaragua and Costa Rica. The people down there seem happier with what they do have than we do with everything that we populate our homes and lives with. They may want some of what we have but they are happier with what they do have than we are.
Anyway . . . this is becoming long . . .
Have an excellent day!
Dave, I wish we had had more time to talk about this tension during the storytelling & place session at Hutchmoot. I’ve been thinking through some of the same issues of staying vs. going regarding my church community. Thanks for sharing!
A very lovely post, and I think you ARE a songwriter.
As self-proclaimed ornithologists, our family would find your backyard a paradise, power lines and all. So good to meet you and Leanne this year!
Thanks for all the comments so far. I want to add that I think one of Wendell Berry’s finest works is his short essay “The Conservation of Nature and the Preservation of Humanity” in Another Turn of the Crank. If you’ve not read it, please do.
I’d also add that community demands compromise. Not the least of which is because once we become a part of a community everyone else has to put up with our nonsense. But also because community requires that we give up something. Freedom. Control. Wishes. Dreams. Ourselves.
The argument is all that sacrifice is worth it. I think that’s true.
Dave,
Thanks for these thoughts. I wish we had had more time to talk Wendell, too. Glad you were at Hutchmoot, and I’m glad you’re wrestling with these questions–which is, at the very least, what Wendell’s trying to get suburbanites to do.
AP
Guess we will have to settle for you and Leanne being our neighbors in heaven, then. Maybe I’ll even get to Berry before that. One can only hope.
Thanks Andrew. And Janna I didn’t say we’d never move, just that moving isn’t the solution.
[...] Dave Bruno….. Of Hutchmoot and Suburbia [...]
If you house had sold, would you have moved?
I think you have to allow yourself to choose caring in the manner that is aligned with your own beliefs. Suburbia, is the beloved goal line of the entire American Dream scam. You can live there and care and inspire others by how you live, or you can move on and inspire others by how you live.
I have lived in suburbia, most my life, but I have found that my dreams don’t fit there any longer, and some are not permitted there by law.
http://unpacktherat.wordpress.com/2011/09/28/richard-says-what-i-think-only-he-says-it-coherently/
Shirley, yes we would have moved, but just down the street to a townhouse. We feel pretty committed to our community for now.
I do agree with you that staying isn’t the only option. It often makes perfect sense to move.
Good luck with everything!
I sometimes think the same thing about Wendell Berry’s work: that he is holding people like himself or people who live in the country up as being more virtuous than the average person. I think that until I go back and re-read his work. He is always very careful to qualify his statements to make clear that he is not saying that. There is a general thrust to his arguments to be sure, but he doesn’t make such simplistic statements. If he did, his work wouldn’t endure as it has.